# Cascade vs ESM Strategy Hub: gap analysis

**Prepared:** 05/11/2026
**Reviewed in Cascade:** *ESM Solution Strategy FY26* (planner, timeline, an objective, an action and two KPIs), plus Home, My work, Kanban, Metrics, Reports, Insights, Capture data and Plans & Teams.
**Read-only:** nothing was changed in Cascade. Every save request was blocked in the browser while browsing, and no forms were submitted.

Effort: **S** = up to a day · **M** = 2–4 days · **L** = a week or more.
IDs (P1, K1 …) are for referring back when you choose what to build.

---

## 1. Recommended shortlist

These are the gaps that matter most for planner use and for tracking KPIs and actions, in suggested order.

| # | ID | What | Why | Effort |
|---|----|------|-----|--------|
| 1 | U1 | **"Post an update" on any KPI or action**, not only monthly objective check-ins | Cascade's main tracking habit. Owners can record progress and a note at any time | M |
| 2 | U2 | **Update schedule per item** with "next update due" and reminders | Each Cascade item shows "Next scheduled Mon 30 Nov". Ours only has the global monthly window | M |
| 3 | K1 | **More KPI target types**: maintain above / below / between, and "stay within budget" | Cascade has 5 types; ours cannot express a range or a budget cap | S–M |
| 4 | A1 | **Action work status** (To do / In progress / Done) separate from health, plus a **Kanban board** | Cascade's "My action board" is how owners work through actions day to day | M |
| 5 | H1 | **Progress-over-time chart** for objectives and actions, with an expected-progress line | Every Cascade item shows its trend. Ours only charts KPIs | M |
| 6 | P1 | Planner **date-horizon filter** (FY, quarters, terms) and **Hide completed** | Both are in Cascade's planner toolbar. Cheap to add | S |
| 7 | P2 | Row actions: **Duplicate, Move to another plan or parent, Convert type** | In Cascade's ⋮ menu. We only have drag-to-move within a plan | M |
| 8 | R1 | **Risk register per item** (impact × likelihood, owner, mitigation) | Cascade has a Risks tab on every item. We only have health "At risk" | M |
| 9 | K2 | **Custom units** (Incidents, Sites, Hours, NPS …) | Cascade lets admins add units. Ours are fixed (currency, %, count, days) | S |
| 10 | H2 | **Activity entries that explain progress**, e.g. "60% → 80% because DSG Portal marked complete" | Answers "why did this move?" without opening the history | S–M |

---

## 2. Planner

| ID | Cascade has | ESM Strategy Hub today | Gap / proposal | Effort |
|----|-------------|------------------------|----------------|--------|
| P1 | Date filter with saved **horizons**: Fiscal year, Q1–Q4, Term 1 / Term 2, custom range, "show past horizons" | Filters for owner, department, status, type and tag. No date filter | Add a horizon picker built from our fiscal year, quarters and terms (they already exist in Admin → Fiscal years). Show only items whose dates overlap | S |
| P1b | Tools → **Hide completed** | Status filter only | Add a "Hide achieved / completed" switch, remembered per user | S |
| P2 | Row ⋮ menu: Open goal hub, View alignment, **Move**, **Convert**, **Duplicate**, Delete | Open details, add child, archive. Drag to move inside the same plan | Add **Duplicate** (with or without children), **Move to another plan or parent**, and **Convert** (e.g. action → KPI, keeping comments and history) | M |
| P3 | Plan ⋮ menu: Favourite, View alignment, Plan settings, Convert, Delete | Favourite, edit, copy to another year, workflow actions | Covered. Nothing needed | – |
| P4 | Inline "+" under each focus area to add an objective | Add KPI / Add action rows plus Add focus area | Covered | – |
| P5 | Objective row shows **timeframe label** ("Fiscal Year 2026") and an **alignment icon** | Dates and owner | Optional: show the horizon name ("FY26", "Q2") instead of raw dates, which is easier to scan | S |
| P6 | **Goal hub**: a full page per item with a shareable link | Drawer with "copy link" | Optional: a full-page item view for sharing in Teams or email | S |

## 3. KPI tracking

| ID | Cascade has | ESM Strategy Hub today | Gap / proposal | Effort |
|----|-------------|------------------------|----------------|--------|
| K1 | Target types: **Reach** (meet or exceed), **Stay within** (don't exceed a budget), **Maintain above**, **Maintain below**, **Maintain between** two values | Direction: increase, decrease, maintain (± tolerance), achieve | Add *maintain above*, *maintain below*, *between* (lower and upper limits) and *stay within budget* (cumulative must not exceed). Status rules extend the existing calculation service | S–M |
| K2 | **Unit library**: %, AED, Incidents, Meetings, Customers, Sites, Providers, Days, Hours, Weeks, Months, Users, NPS, plus "create by typing" | Fixed: AED, QAR, SAR, %, count, days | Admin-managed unit list. Currency units still drive FX conversion | S |
| K3 | **Evaluation method**: *Stepped* (judged at each milestone) or *Continuous* (expected progress recalculated daily) | Stepped only (phased period targets) | Add *Continuous*: expected progress pro-rated within the month. This gives fairer mid-month status | S |
| K4 | **Evaluation period and day** per KPI (monthly / quarterly …, "last day of the month / quarter") | Frequency per KPI; the monthly rhythm is global | Show per-KPI due dates (ties into U2) | S |
| K5 | Targets **auto-generated** from the period, editable as dated datapoints | Phased targets per period, entered in a grid | Covered. Optional "spread evenly" and "copy last year's phasing" buttons | S |
| K6 | **"This measure needs tracking"** banner when no target or metric is set | KPIs get default values | Flag KPIs with no target or baseline as *Needs setup* in the planner and Home. Useful for data quality, and Cascade has several such KPIs (e.g. "IT operating costs to remain within approved annual budget") | S |
| K7 | **Metrics Library** (reusable metrics, several KPIs linked to one), **Connect metrics** (integrations) and **Metrics trees** | KPI library (FR-KPI-08) and Excel import | Integrations are out of scope (FR-KPI-06). A **metric tree** (how KPIs roll up to Group KPIs) could be a read-only view over the `sums_children` links | M |

## 4. Action tracking

| ID | Cascade has | ESM Strategy Hub today | Gap / proposal | Effort |
|----|-------------|------------------------|----------------|--------|
| A1 | **Work status** (To do / In progress / Done) separate from health. **Kanban "My action board"** with "Move to done" and "4/5 tasks done" on each card | Health and % complete only | Add `work_status` to actions, plus a Kanban page (columns by status, drag between them; Done sets 100% when progress is manual) | M |
| A2 | Progress methods: **checklist** (dated items), **manual**, and progress from child items | Manual %, milestones, checklist | Covered | – |
| A3 | Checklist items have **due dates**, show "next item" on the card, and progress updates automatically | Same, with milestone due dates and an overdue flag | Covered. Optional: show the next open item under the action in the planner | S |
| A4 | Action **expected progress** line ("Last day of the month") | Expected-by-now marker on the bar | Covered by H1 | – |
| A5 | — | Budget (AED), priority, dependencies | **Ours is ahead.** Keep | – |

## 5. Updates, reminders and history

| ID | Cascade has | ESM Strategy Hub today | Gap / proposal | Effort |
|----|-------------|------------------------|----------------|--------|
| U1 | **Post an update** on any item: title, rich text, attachments, the current progress shown ("80% / 100%"), listed in an Updates tab | Monthly check-in on objectives (narrative, wins, issues, next steps). KPI actuals have a comment. Actions have none | Generalise check-ins into **Updates** for objectives, KPIs and actions. Monthly check-ins stay as the structured form, and ad-hoc updates are allowed between them | M |
| U2 | **Update schedule per item** ("Next scheduled Mon Nov 30 2026") and **reminder notifications** ("Post new progress update for action X by …") | One global rhythm (window opens on day 1, closes on working day 5) | Per-item schedule (default: monthly rhythm; can be set to quarterly / termly), plus a "next update due" column on the planner, Home and My work | M |
| H1 | **Progress chart** on every objective, action and KPI (Sep → Aug) with an expected line | KPI chart only. `item_progress` stores one row per item per year (no history) | Store progress per period (snapshot at period lock) and chart it in the drawer | M |
| H2 | **Activity** that explains changes: "progress 60% → 80% based on: DSG Portal Enhancement marked as complete" | History tab from the audit log (field, old → new) | Write the cause into the progress audit entry and show it in the History tab | S–M |
| H3 | Comments on every item | Comments with @mentions and replies | Covered (ours has replies) | – |

## 6. Risks

| ID | Cascade has | ESM Strategy Hub today | Gap / proposal | Effort |
|----|-------------|------------------------|----------------|--------|
| R1 | **Risks tab** on every item: "Identify the potential risks … prioritise by impact and likelihood". Objectives show "No risks have been identified" | Health status, at-risk roll-up flag, leadership "needs attention" | Risk register: title, impact (1–5), likelihood (1–5), score, owner, mitigation, status. Shown on the item, in the leadership pack and on the dashboard (top risks by score) | M |

## 7. Other modules

| ID | Cascade has | ESM Strategy Hub today | Gap / proposal | Effort |
|----|-------------|------------------------|----------------|--------|
| W1 | **My work**: every active goal I own or collaborate on, table or timeline, group by plan, type filter, "Update due on" column, "% on track" headline | Home "My objectives and KPIs" table with a type filter | Add a **My work** page (or Home tab) with group-by, a timeline view and an "update due" column | S–M |
| W2 | **Kanban** | — | See A1 | – |
| F1 | **Focus areas library**: each focus area across all plans with plan count, objective count, commences / retires dates and health | Focus areas are per plan. The dashboard groups them by name | Read-only "Focus areas" page across plans. Optional *commences / retires* dates | S |
| RP1 | **Report builder** with templates (Executive Quarterly Review, Leaders Dashboard, Focus area Deep Dive) and saved, shared reports | Leadership pack (PDF / PPT), dashboards and Excel exports. Quarterly and year-end templates are not built yet (FR-REV-05) | Build the **Quarterly** and **Year-end** pack templates first. A free-form report builder is probably not worth it | M |
| AI1 | **AI overview** on each objective ("Tapestry"), plus *Highlight key risks*, *Suggest plan of attack* and *Ask AI* | Not built (phase 3, FR-ADM-05) | Generate an AI summary per objective and focus area from progress, check-ins and KPI data. Also useful as the leadership pack narrative | M |
| AI2 | **Capture data → Upload transcript / Upload files** (early access): extracts insights from meeting transcripts and documents | Excel import of KPI actuals | Phase 3: upload leadership meeting minutes and let AI propose decisions and updates for review | L |
| T1 | **Teams** (empty in ESM's workspace) | Org units (departments and teams) | Covered. Ours is used and Cascade's is not | – |

---

## 8. Making the system easier to use (not in Cascade either)

| ID | Idea | Effort |
|----|------|--------|
| E1 | **Quick update from the planner row**: click the % or the status to enter a KPI actual or an action % in a small popover, without opening the drawer | S–M |
| E2 | **One "My updates" queue**: Capture data lists only what is due *for me* (from U2 schedules), sorted by due date, with "Done" ticks | S (after U2) |
| E3 | **Suggested status + reason only when overriding**: pre-select the calculated status in check-ins and ask for a reason only if the owner picks a different one | S |
| E4 | **"Needs setup" warnings** for KPIs without a target, actions without an owner or dates, and objectives with no KPI or action (K6 extended) | S |
| E5 | **KPI templates from the library** when adding a KPI (unit, target type and frequency pre-filled) | S |
| E6 | **Teams / email digest**: one weekly message per owner listing what is due and what is overdue, instead of one notification per item | S |

## 9. Where ESM Strategy Hub is already ahead (keep these)

- The monthly rhythm with window, escalation and **period lock**, and the leadership pack generated from locked data.
- Plan **approval workflow** (draft → in review → approved) and change requests after approval.
- **Alignment gap check** (Group objectives with no department support, department objectives aligned to nothing).
- **Year-end close wizard** (carry forward, close achieved or missed, convert to multi-year).
- **Phased targets per period**, multi-year KPIs and **multi-currency with FX**.
- Action **budget, priority and dependencies**; the Timeline with drag-to-reschedule and dependency arrows.
- "Why this status?" explanations on every status chip.

## 10. For the Cascade data migration (SRS 11.2)

Seen in the FY26 plan. These will affect the import mapping:

- Some Cascade KPIs have **no tracking set up** (no target or metric). They will import as *Needs setup* (K6).
- Cascade KPIs use **"Reach"** with an initial value and target, plus a **lower limit**. Map them to our baseline, target and *maintain above* (needs K1).
- Action progress in Cascade is often **checklist-based with dated items**. These map directly to our checklist milestones.
- Cascade reminders are per item, on the last day of the month or quarter. Map them to U2 schedules if built.

## 11. Decisions needed from you

1. Which shortlist items (section 1) to build, and in what order.
2. **A1 Kanban:** do actions need a work status (To do / In progress / Done) at ESM, or is % complete enough?
3. **U1 / U2:** keep the single monthly window as the only rhythm, or allow per-item schedules (e.g. quarterly KPIs)?
4. **R1 Risks:** a full risk register, or just a "key risk" text field on objectives?
5. **AI (AI1 / AI2):** start phase 3 now or after go-live?
